Lost in .NET Code

Developing software in .NET, Security and other ramblings.

Ado.Net Entity Framework Vote of no confidence ??

Tuesday, June 24, 2008

**RANT**
http://efvote.wufoo.com/forms/ado-net-entity-framework-vote-of-no-confidence/

So I read Tim Mallalieu's blog he is on my RSS feed one of few select people I track and trace. (Tim if you read this I am not a stalker honest, I just think you post are cool and informative)

http://blogs.msdn.com/timmall/archive/2008/06/24/vote-of-no-confidence.aspx

So I read the following post, and fell off my chair, somebody has gone to the effort of actually putting togther a ADO.NET Entity Framework Vote of no confidence. Now forget the techie part lets just look a the practical, because obivously I am missing something. Surely and strike me down with a feather duster that if you don't like the Entity Framework ....You just don't use it ooooorrr, even better and maybe a more postive thing than moaning about a product write you own, develop an open source alternative, dare I say it... use something else.

It is really easy to sit on the side line and snip about a framework that does not fit your needs or you believe is wrong, but come on now give the guys and girls who have slaved over the Entity framework a break constructive critisim fine and in the post above they have made some (fair enough) but to finish it with please make a vote of no confidence is not exactly nice and in just is in my view rude. Yes I suppose you have got the attention of the team.. but surely there is a better way, how to motive a team to your ideas.

I personally don't use Entity Framework or Linq SQL (I have tried) but I am big fan of LLBGEN Pro, it works, it's solid and fits my clients and my needs. I made a choice, not bashed a team that was trying to build a very complex product. Have some respect please don't sign a petition just give sensible feedback through normal challenge.. or dare I say don't use it....
**END RANT**

Apologies for the Rant. Good luck to the Entity Framework team, please look at some of the criticims leveled it is correct, but I am sure you would review it just like Classic ASP is better than ASP.NET v1 and ASP.NET 2 is better than ASP.NET v1. It will be a process of learning, would love to see how many developers get frameworks out of the box correct. I will admit I don't always do, that is the part of being human, my first Sage Framework in C# sucked my revision at the moment does not..

I am missing something do we need vote of no confidence.. No, just MS to be listening which I hope they are, and for sensible suggestions in a reasonable manner.

Labels: ,


Subscribe in a reader


Blogs I read

Tristan Phillips
Sarah Blow (.Net Mobile)
Mike Taulty (MS DPE)
Ian Griffths (WPF)
Jack Greenfield


Useful Links

Fircroft Trust Ltd
Unwind Software Ltd


Archives

December 2006   January 2007   February 2007   March 2007   April 2007   May 2007   June 2007   October 2007   November 2007   February 2008   April 2008   May 2008   June 2008   July 2008   August 2008   October 2008   November 2008  


Fun and Games



 

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?